The Misplaced Trust: GPS Tracking Exposes Failures in Waste Management
- Introduction
The escalating volume of waste generated globally presents a formidable challenge to environmental sustainability and public health. In response, principles of the circular economy have gained prominence, advocating for the efficient use of resources and the minimization of waste through practices like recycling and responsible disposal methods such as legal pyrolysis. These approaches aim to transform waste from a burden into a valuable resource, reducing the strain on natural environments and fostering a more sustainable future.1 However, the efficacy of these systems hinges on transparency and accountability throughout the waste management chain.
In recent years, the application of Global Positioning System (GPS) tracking technology has emerged as a powerful tool for scrutinizing the often-opaque world of waste disposal. By attaching small, inconspicuous trackers to discarded items, investigators can monitor their journey from collection to final destination. This technology offers the potential to shed light on the actual practices of waste management companies and to verify whether waste is being handled according to intended procedures and environmental regulations.2 The repeated use of GPS tracking in investigations by journalists, non-governmental organizations, and even parliamentary bodies underscores its value in providing tangible evidence of waste mismanagement that might otherwise remain concealed.
This report aims to present documented instances, supported by credible sources, where GPS tracking has played a pivotal role in revealing two critical forms of waste mismanagement: the disposal of recyclable materials in landfills and the diversion of waste intended for legal pyrolysis to unauthorized and environmentally harmful facilities. By examining these case studies, this analysis seeks to illuminate the realities of current waste management practices and to underscore the urgent need for greater oversight and reform to ensure the integrity of these vital systems.
- Case Studies: GPS Tracking Reveals Recyclables Sent to Landfills
- Del Mar, California (June 2024): The Journey of a Plastic Bottle to a Riverside Landfill:
In June 2024, a resident of Del Mar, California, Kevin Grold, decided to investigate the fate of his household recycling.17 Driven by a desire to ensure his efforts to recycle were indeed contributing to environmental preservation, Grold purchased an inexpensive GPS tracking device online. He attached this tracker to a plastic water bottle and placed it in his designated recycling bin. The initial tracking data showed the bottle’s journey to a recycling center located in Escondido, seemingly confirming the proper handling of the item. However, Grold continued to monitor the tracker’s location, and several hours later, he observed its movement further north, ultimately pinpointing its final location at a landfill in Riverside.17 This discovery was disheartening for Grold, who viewed recycling as a personal commitment to environmental stewardship.18 He noted information on the website of his recycling service provider, EDCO, which explained that even minimal contamination in a recycling bin could lead to the rejection of an entire load.17 This explanation, coupled with the low national plastic recycling rate of approximately 5% reported by EarthDay.org and I Love A Clean San Diego, prompted Grold to speculate about the possibility of a magnet at the recycling facility accidentally rejecting the bottle with the tracker, or the more concerning possibility that recyclables are not consistently processed as intended.17 Subsequent experiments conducted by Grold with other plastic and cardboard items showed that they did reach recycling centers for processing, but their ultimate destination remained unknown.17 This personal investigation underscores the potential for items seemingly destined for recycling to end up in landfills, raising questions about the efficiency and transparency of the recycling process as experienced by everyday consumers.
- Los Angeles, California (Ongoing): Tracking Starbucks Single-Use Cups to Orange County Landfills:
A significant investigation by KCAL News in Los Angeles brought to light the questionable fate of Starbucks single-use plastic cups that consumers diligently place in recycling bins.19 Former high-tech executive Susan Keefe embarked on an experiment to track these ubiquitous cups, which constitute a substantial portion of Starbucks’ sales.19 Keefe placed trackers inside used iced drink cups and deposited them in Starbucks’ own recycling bins. By following the trucks that collected the recyclables, she discovered that a significant number of these cups were ultimately transported to a landfill in Orange County.19 This outcome was far from Keefe’s expectation, as she aimed to see the plastic recycled. KCAL News further conducted their own tracking experiment, placing a tracker in a cup at an East Los Angeles Starbucks. This cup was tracked to a waste transfer center just a mile and a half away, a location experts indicated is often a precursor to landfill disposal.19 Another cup dropped in Hollywood traveled 13 miles to a waste transfer center in Sun Valley that also operates as a materials recovery facility (MRF). A third cup from Beverly Hills ended up 18 miles away at another Sun Valley MRF. While an employee at this facility claimed the plastic items are recovered and shipped out, an expert expressed skepticism about their likelihood of being truly recycled.19 Expanding the scope nationally, CBS News investigative teams tracked 57 cups placed in Starbucks recycling bins across 18 cities. Of these, possible locations were found for 36 cups, with a mere four reaching facilities that appeared to be genuine recovery centers. Alarmingly, 14 cups ended up at locations resembling landfills.19 Starbucks executives acknowledged these findings as “unacceptable” and “disappointing,” suggesting that factors outside their direct control, such as contamination or mixed materials, could explain why the cups do not always reach their intended recycling destinations.19 However, the investigator in the initial KCAL News report asserted that Starbucks is actively misleading the public with their recycling claims.19 In contrast to the findings with the Starbucks cups, a separate instance involved a plastic bottle and an aluminum can deposited in recycling bins at a CBS Broadcast Center, where the bottle was tracked to a recycling center and the can’s last recorded location suggested it might have been crushed for recycling.19 This comprehensive investigation highlights a potential disconnect between the intended recycling pathway for a specific product and its actual fate, raising concerns about corporate responsibility and the effectiveness of recycling programs for certain types of waste.
- Houston, Texas (October 2022): Plastic Waste from a Recycling Program Ends Up in a Remote Landfill:
In Houston, Texas, the promise of advanced plastic recycling was put to the test by local activist Brandy Deason.20 Deason participated in the Houston Recycling Collaboration, a public-private partnership that launched with the support of Exxon and advertised its ability to chemically recycle any type of plastic.20 To ascertain the reality of this claim, Deason placed an Apple Tag tracking device in her bagged plastic waste and deposited it at one of the program’s drop-off sites.20 However, an investigation by Inside Climate News and CBS, conducted with Deason’s assistance, revealed a starkly different outcome.20 The tagged plastic bags were tracked to Wright Waste Management, a remote facility situated 20 miles outside of Houston’s downtown area.20 Aerial drone footage of this site showed a vast, open-air pile of trash, strongly suggesting that the plastic waste was being landfilled rather than recycled.20 Adding to the concerning findings, the promised “advanced recycling” facility, which was supposed to enact the chemical recycling process, had not even opened, nearly two years after the program’s launch, and was not expected to be operational until the following year.20 Despite the lack of an operational recycling plant, the Houston Recycling Collaboration had expanded its drop-off locations, a move that, according to the investigation, appeared to be funneling an increasing amount of plastic waste to the Wright facility, which was described as little more than a “glorified landfill”.20 Further scrutiny revealed potential safety hazards at the Wright facility. Experts who spoke to Inside Climate News noted that storing large quantities of plastic waste in the Texas heat could pose a significant fire risk.20 Public records obtained by the news outlets through a documents request showed that the facility had failed fire marshal inspections on three separate occasions between July 2023 and April 2024 due to missing permits related to the storage of hazardous and combustible materials.20 Deason, who consciously tries to minimize her own plastic consumption, expressed her alarm at learning where her unavoidable plastic waste ended up, fearing that a fire at the facility could release poisonous emissions harmful to nearby residents.20 This case illustrates a potential instance where a recycling program, despite its claims of advanced technology, may have been misleading the public, with recyclable materials being directly disposed of in a landfill, accompanied by significant environmental and safety risks.
- Indianapolis, Indiana (November 2023): Curbside Recycling Tracked, Highlighting Contamination Issues:
An investigation by WTHR’s 13 Investigates in Indianapolis sought to determine the actual fate of curbside recycling collected from residents.21 Over a three-month period in November 2023, the investigative team collaborated with local families to track their recycling using GPS tracking devices placed inside plastic bottles.21 They also employed undercover cameras and even a drone to follow the recycling trucks from the curb to their final destination.21 The investigation focused on recycling collected by the two largest waste management companies serving central Indiana: Republic Services and Waste Management.21 For Republic Services, trackers placed in recycling bins from households in northeast Indianapolis and the west side of the city were followed to a large property owned by the company on the northwest side of Indianapolis.21 This facility housed both a materials recovery facility (MRF) for processing recyclables and a transfer station for trash. In both instances, the recycling trucks were observed dumping their entire loads inside the MRF, and GPS data confirmed the trackers’ locations within the facility.21 Undercover cameras captured footage of a front loader moving the dumped materials onto the recycling processing line.21 The signal from one tracker stopped within 20 minutes, likely due to the harsh environment of the MRF’s machinery.21 For Waste Management, a tracker placed in a recycling bin near Brownsburg was followed to a large warehouse in an industrial complex in Indianapolis, identified by the tracker’s location as being inside a large pile of recently dumped material.21 Video footage corroborated the presence of this pile and a front loader moving material to a recycling sorting area. The tracker continued to transmit its location from the same spot for five days before the signal ceased.21 Waste Management confirmed this warehouse as their primary recycling processing center for central Indiana.21 Similarly, a tracker placed in a 13News employee’s recycling bin in Westfield also ended up at the same Indianapolis facility, but its journey included a stop at a WM transfer station in Whitestown before being transported to Indianapolis.21 An unexpected finding occurred with a tracker placed in a recycling bin in Morristown. While the Waste Management truck initially appeared to be heading towards a landfill, it ultimately went to a nearby transfer station, and the recyclable material was later transported to Waste Management’s Indianapolis MRF.21 Overall, the investigation provided evidence that the tracked curbside recyclable materials collected by both Republic Services and Waste Management in central Indiana were indeed transported to their respective recycling processing centers.21 Tours of these facilities revealed the processes of sorting and baling recyclable materials for shipment to other companies that would use them to create new products.21 However, the investigation also highlighted a significant issue of contamination, with a substantial percentage of the materials placed in recycling bins being non-recyclable and therefore likely destined for landfills.21 This suggests that while the initial stages of recycling collection and transportation may be functioning as intended, the presence of non-recyclable items in the bins can still lead to waste ending up in landfills.
- San Diego County, California (July 2024): Tracking Various Plastic Recyclables:
In another investigation in San Diego County, California, CBS 8 employed Apple AirTags to track the journey of various types of plastic recyclables.22 The experiment involved placing AirTags inside a water bottle, a yogurt container, an orange juice bottle, and a wipes container. These items were then placed in recycling bins in different areas of San Diego County, utilizing different waste pickup companies.22 The goal was to gain insight into the diverse paths that common household recyclables might take after collection. Representatives from “I Love a Clean San Diego” provided context, explaining that the fate of these recyclables could vary significantly. Some might be processed at local facilities and then sold for reuse, while others could be shipped out of the county to different processing centers, potentially even being sold to foreign countries and transported across the ocean. The organization also acknowledged the possibility that some recyclables might ultimately end up in landfills if they cannot be effectively processed or if markets for the recycled materials are not available.22 This experiment underscores the complexity and uncertainty inherent in the recycling process for consumers. Even within the same geographical area, recyclables collected by different companies might follow vastly different routes, with the possibility of landfill disposal remaining a significant concern for a portion of the collected materials. The lack of a single, transparent pathway highlights the need for better tracking and reporting mechanisms to provide consumers with a clearer understanding of where their recycling actually goes.
- London (April 2022): Bloomberg Investigation Traces Tesco’s “Recycled” Plastic to Poland: A Bloomberg Quicktake investigation in April 2022 sought to unravel the journey of plastic waste that consumers diligently deposit in recycling bins at Tesco supermarkets in London.10 Bloomberg reporters placed small GPS trackers inside three used plastic items: a vegetable film, a snack pouch, and a Tesco-branded shopping bag. These items were then placed in public-facing recycling collection bins at various Tesco locations across London.23 The ensuing investigation revealed a complex and multi-stage journey that extended far beyond the borders of the UK.23 The trackers showed the plastic waste being transported to large logistics depots outside of London before being trucked to Harwich International Port.23 From there, the waste was shipped across the North Sea to Rotterdam and then continued its journey eastward through Germany into Poland, eventually ending up near the town of Zielona Gora, approximately 700 miles from London.23 In Zielona Gora, the plastic was traced to a waste processing center owned by the Eurokey Recycling Group, a company identified as a “waste broker” rather than a primary recycler.23 Eurokey’s primary function was to sort the various types of plastic waste it received and then send them on to other contractors or buyers for further processing or disposal.23 Bloomberg reporters who visited the Eurokey warehouse observed large bales of plastic film piled up in a gated yard.23 The mayor of Zielona Gora confirmed that the town receives a substantial and continuous flow of garbage from the UK, noting that the lower cost of waste disposal in Poland compared to countries like the UK or Germany made it an attractive destination for waste entrepreneurs.23 He was, however, unaware of the specific fate of the Tesco plastic once it left the Eurokey facility.23 Further investigation into the destinations of the tracked items revealed that the clear vegetable wrap’s signal was lost within London, near the River Thames.23 The tracker in the snack wrapper led to a factory in East Poland operated by Stella Pack SA, a manufacturer of plastic bags. Stella Pack reported that they sort, melt, and granulate the received waste to produce recycled garbage bags, with any unsuitable plastic being incinerated to generate power for the facility.23 The tracker in the Tesco carrier bag stopped transmitting its location in Zielona Gora. However, subsequent inquiries revealed that an unmarked truck leaving the Eurokey warehouse was traveling east towards one of the largest cement factories in the region. Lafarge SA, a major cement producer, confirmed that their plant near Inowroclaw uses waste, including plastic, as a significant source of fuel, with Eurokey being one of their suppliers through a broker. Lafarge considers this “waste-to-energy” process a sustainable solution due to the high temperatures in their kilns, which they claim destroy even harmful toxins.23 Critics, however, point out that burning plastic still contributes to carbon dioxide emissions.23 Adding to the complexity, two former Eurokey employees in Poland claimed to have witnessed low-quality Tesco plastic being disposed of in landfills, sometimes misclassified as Polish domestic waste, although Eurokey denied these allegations.23 The investigation also revealed that the tracker in the Tesco bag later showed a signal from southern Turkey, in an industrial zone near Adana, approximately 2,000 miles from London. The plastic had been purchased by a recycling company called IMO Plastik, which initially reported that they would attempt to recycle as much as possible, despite the poor quality of the bales received from Europe. Experts expressed doubt about this high recovery claim, and the manager later denied accepting exports, contradicting the tracker data.23 This intricate journey, involving numerous intermediaries and crossing international borders, highlights the significant challenges in ensuring that plastic waste deposited for recycling in the UK is indeed recycled effectively and sustainably, with a considerable portion potentially ending up incinerated or in landfills abroad.
- Case Studies: GPS Tracking Uncovers Waste Sent to Illegal Pyrolysis Facilities
- BBC Investigation (March 2025): Millions of UK Tyres Meant for Recycling Found in Unregulated Pyrolysis Plants in India:
A comprehensive investigation conducted by BBC’s File on 4 in collaboration with journalism group SourceMaterial in March 2025 uncovered a disturbing practice: millions of end-of-life tyres exported from the United Kingdom to India under the pretense of recycling are instead being incinerated in makeshift and illegal pyrolysis facilities.4 The investigation revealed that the UK produces approximately 50 million waste tyres each year, with nearly half of this volume being shipped abroad, predominantly to India.4 Within the tyre recycling industry, it is reportedly an “open secret” that a significant proportion of these exported tyres do not end up in legitimate recycling facilities.4 The Tyre Recovery Association (TRA) estimates that around 70 percent of imported tyres in India are diverted to unlicensed pyrolysis plants.4 These unregulated facilities typically employ rudimentary batch pyrolysis, a process involving heating tyres to around 500 degrees Celsius in an oxygen-free environment to extract steel, small quantities of oil, and carbon black.4 However, due to the lack of pollution control measures and regulatory oversight, this process releases substantial amounts of toxic gases and hazardous chemicals into the environment.4 The emissions from these illegal operations have been shown to contaminate local water sources, degrade surrounding vegetation, and contribute to severe respiratory conditions among residents living nearby, who report chronic coughs, eye irritation, and difficulty breathing due to prolonged exposure to soot and chemical fumes.4 To track the supply chain of these exported tyres, the BBC, in collaboration with SourceMaterial, strategically placed hidden GPS tracking devices within tyre shipments originating from the UK.4 The data from these trackers unequivocally demonstrated that the tyres reached illegal pyrolysis sites located in remote areas of India, where they were subsequently burned under unsafe conditions, releasing harmful pollutants into the atmosphere.4 The investigation also highlighted a tragic incident in January 2025, when an explosion at one such illegal pyrolysis plant in Wada, near Mumbai, resulted in the deaths of four people, including two children.4 This particular plant was reportedly processing tyres sourced from Europe and lacked even basic safety protocols.4 Following this fatal incident, local authorities shut down seven similar plants in the region.4 However, environmental activists estimate that hundreds of illegal pyrolysis facilities continue to operate across India, exacerbating the country’s air pollution crisis.4 Although the Indian government has officially banned the use of imported tyres in pyrolysis, the investigation revealed that enforcement of this ban has been weak.4 An environmental lawyer interviewed by the BBC estimated that roughly half of the approximately 2,000 pyrolysis plants operating in India are unlicensed, rendering meaningful pollution control nearly impossible.4 This investigation starkly illustrates a significant case of international waste crime, where waste intended for legitimate recycling processes is instead being diverted to illegal and highly polluting facilities, with severe consequences for both the environment and public health in India.
- UK Parliamentary Debate (April 2025): Discussion on Illegal and Hazardous Processing of Exported Tyres:
The findings of the BBC investigation into the export of UK waste tyres to India for illegal pyrolysis were further corroborated and discussed during a Westminster Hall debate in the UK Parliament on April 29, 2025.7 Members of Parliament (MPs) convened to address the urgent need for reforms in the management of end-of-life tyres in the UK, with a particular focus on the environmental, health, and economic concerns associated with the export of approximately 350,000 tonnes of used tyres annually to India.7 During the debate, concerns were raised regarding the illegal and hazardous processing of these exported tyres in primitive batch pyrolysis plants in India, where lax environmental enforcement allows for the production of high-sulphur heavy fuel oils and low-grade carbon black, often accompanied by the release of harmful emissions without any filtration.7 Evidence derived from GPS tracking studies was specifically referenced during the debate, consistently demonstrating that tyres exported from the UK were ending up in unregulated facilities, confirming the findings of the BBC investigation.7 MPs highlighted several deficiencies in the UK’s regulatory framework that facilitate this illegal trade, including the classification of end-of-life tyres as “green list waste,” which makes them difficult to track and regulate, and the T8 waste exemption, which allows operators to self-certify without the need for permits, thereby facilitating unregulated exports.7 The debate also touched upon the unused powers granted by the Environment Act 2021, which were intended to enhance the tracking and management of waste exports.7 Tessa Munt MP specifically called for the urgent removal of tyres from the green list, stricter licensing requirements for exporters, and more rigorous enforcement of existing laws.7 The debate also drew attention to the successful legislation implemented in Australia, which requires tyres to be shredded before export, coupled with strict licensing and verification schemes, as a potential model for the UK to emulate.7 This parliamentary discussion underscores the recognition at a policy level of the problem of UK tyre exports ending up in illegal pyrolysis facilities in India, with GPS tracking evidence playing a crucial role in informing this concern and prompting consideration of stronger regulatory measures.
- Analysis and Implications
The case studies presented above reveal several concerning patterns in waste management practices across different geographical locations and waste streams. A notable theme is the geographical disparity in the nature of mismanagement. In developed nations like the United States and the United Kingdom, instances of recyclables being sent to landfills are more prevalent, often linked to contamination, economic factors, and the complexities of sorting mixed waste streams. In contrast, the case of tyre exports from the UK to India highlights a scenario where waste is intentionally diverted to illegal and environmentally damaging processing facilities in a developing country, driven by economic incentives and weaker regulatory oversight.4
The types of waste tracked also provide valuable insights. Plastic waste consistently features in cases of recyclables ending up in landfills 17, suggesting inherent challenges in the collection, sorting, and economic viability of recycling various types of plastics. Similarly, end-of-life tyres represent a significant waste stream prone to illegal disposal methods like unregulated pyrolysis.4
The crucial role of investigative journalism in uncovering these instances of waste mismanagement cannot be overstated.4 These investigations, often utilizing GPS tracking as a primary tool, have brought to light practices that might otherwise remain hidden from public scrutiny and regulatory bodies, suggesting potential gaps in official oversight and monitoring mechanisms.
Economic factors appear to play a significant role in driving waste mismanagement. The lower costs associated with landfill disposal compared to the complexities and costs of recycling can incentivize the former, especially when contamination issues arise.17 Similarly, the financial benefits of exporting waste to countries with lower disposal costs and less stringent environmental regulations can motivate the diversion of waste to illegal facilities like the tyre pyrolysis plants in India.4
A recurring theme across the case studies is the presence of regulatory weaknesses and inadequate enforcement that enable these illegal practices to persist. Loopholes in regulations, such as the UK’s classification of tyres as “green list waste” and the T8 waste exemption 7, can be exploited to facilitate the export of waste for improper disposal. Furthermore, even when regulations are in place, as with the ban on imported tyres for pyrolysis in India, weak enforcement can render these regulations ineffective.4
The environmental and health consequences of mismanaged waste are significant. Landfills, while a necessary part of waste management, can contribute to land use issues, generate leachate that can contaminate soil and groundwater, and release greenhouse gases like methane.24 The presence of plastics in landfills poses particular concerns due to their slow degradation and potential to leach harmful chemicals.17 Illegal pyrolysis, as evidenced by the tyre burning in India, results in severe air and water pollution, soil contamination, and significant health problems for local populations, including respiratory illnesses and eye irritation.4 The potential for fires in large piles of plastic waste, as highlighted in the Houston case, further underscores the environmental risks associated with improper waste handling.20
Addressing these issues requires a focus on the regulatory landscape. The UK’s classification of end-of-life tyres as “green list waste” under waste shipment regulations makes it difficult to track their movement and ensure proper disposal.7 This classification contrasts with the environmental and health risks associated with their illegal processing. The T8 waste exemption in the UK further complicates matters by allowing smaller operators to store and process up to 40 tonnes of tyres weekly without requiring a full environmental permit.7 This exemption has been identified as a loophole that less responsible operators can exploit to export baled tyres to countries like India for use in rudimentary batch pyrolysis plants.13 The Australian government’s approach, which involves requiring tyres to be shredded before export and implementing a system of notification and licensing for exporters, offers a potential solution by making it more difficult for whole tyres to be used in illegal pyrolysis plants.7 While India has banned the use of imported tyres for pyrolysis, the weak enforcement of this ban allows hundreds of illegal facilities to continue operating.4
Ultimately, greater transparency and accountability are paramount in the waste management industry.10 The discrepancies revealed by GPS tracking investigations between intended disposal methods and actual outcomes erode public trust in recycling programs and waste management companies.19 The implementation of mandatory digital waste tracking systems, such as the one planned for the UK starting in April 2025 25, holds promise for improving the ability to monitor waste movements and reduce waste crime. Such systems aim to create a centralized database where all waste data is stored, allowing for better tracking from the point of origin to the final destination.25 Technologies like GPS tracking, sensor-equipped bins, and RFID tags can contribute to this enhanced transparency by providing real-time data on the location and status of waste throughout the management process.24
To better understand the scope of waste mismanagement uncovered by GPS tracking, the following table summarizes the key incidents discussed in this report:
| Location |
Date (Approx.) |
Type of Waste Tracked |
Intended Destination |
Actual Destination |
Source (Snippet IDs) |
| Del Mar, CA |
June 2024 |
Plastic Bottle |
Recycling Center |
Landfill |
CBS 8 17 |
| Orange County, CA |
Ongoing |
Starbucks Cups |
Recycling Bins |
Landfill |
KCAL Investigates/CBS News 19 |
| Houston, TX |
Oct 2022 |
Bagged Plastic |
Recycling Program |
Landfill |
Futurism/Inside Climate News/CBS 20 |
| Indianapolis, IN |
Nov 2023 |
Plastic Bottles |
Recycling Bins |
Recycling Facilities (but issue of contamination) |
WTHR 13 Investigates 21 |
| London, UK |
Apr 2022 |
Mixed Soft Plastics |
Recycling Bins |
Poland (processing, potential landfill/incineration) |
Bloomberg 10 |
| UK to India |
Mar 2025 |
Waste Tyres |
Legal Recycling |
Illegal Pyrolysis Plants |
BBC News, UK Parliament Hansard, Tyre Recovery Association 4 |
The regulatory landscape plays a crucial role in preventing waste mismanagement. The following table highlights some of the regulatory issues identified in the report and potential solutions:
| Regulatory Issue |
Location/Context |
Evidence (Snippet IDs) |
Proposed Solution/Example |
| “Green List” classification of tyres |
UK Exports to India |
7 |
Reclassification as “hazardous waste” 5 |
| UK T8 Waste Exemption for Tyres |
UK Exports to India |
7 |
Removal of the exemption 7 |
| Weak enforcement of pyrolysis ban |
India (imported tyres) |
4 |
Stronger enforcement by Indian authorities 5 |
| Export of whole tyres |
UK to India |
7 |
Requirement for shredding before export (Australia’s model) 7 |
| Lack of comprehensive waste tracking |
UK (general) |
25 |
Implementation of mandatory digital waste tracking 25 |
- Conclusion and Recommendations
The findings from the GPS tracking investigations detailed in this report paint a concerning picture of waste management practices. Numerous instances reveal that materials intended for recycling are ending up in landfills, both domestically in the US and internationally in the case of the UK’s plastic waste. Furthermore, the investigation into UK tyre exports to India has exposed a widespread practice of diverting waste intended for recycling to illegal and highly polluting pyrolysis facilities. These revelations underscore the limitations and failures in current waste management systems and highlight the critical role that technologies like GPS tracking play in bringing these issues to light.
To address these systemic problems, several key recommendations emerge. Governments must implement stricter regulations on waste management practices, including more precise definitions of what constitutes “recyclable” and the establishment of robust tracking mechanisms that extend throughout the entire waste management chain. Enhanced enforcement of existing regulations is equally crucial to deter illegal disposal and processing activities, both within national borders and in the context of international waste trade. Specific regulatory loopholes, such as the UK’s T8 waste exemption for tyre exports, must be closed, and international cooperation needs to be strengthened to effectively combat the illegal movement and disposal of waste.
Significant investment in domestic recycling infrastructure is also essential to reduce reliance on waste exports and to ensure that recyclable materials are processed properly and sustainably. This includes supporting the development and adoption of advanced sorting technologies and innovative recycling methods. While traditional pyrolysis in unregulated settings has proven harmful, the potential of advanced pyrolysis technologies in legal and strictly controlled environments for handling certain types of waste should be explored.26
The continued use and expansion of technologies like GPS tracking are vital for improving waste monitoring and detecting instances of mismanagement. Furthermore, the adoption of other technologies such as sensor-equipped bins, RFID tracking, and comprehensive digital waste tracking systems can contribute significantly to enhancing transparency and accountability across the waste management sector.24
In conclusion, the evidence presented in this report underscores the urgent need for comprehensive reforms in waste management practices. The findings from GPS tracking investigations serve as a stark reminder that the intended pathways for waste disposal are not always followed, with potentially serious environmental and health consequences. Policymakers, industry stakeholders, and consumers must work collaboratively to implement stricter regulations, enhance enforcement, invest in sustainable infrastructure, and leverage technology to ensure a more transparent and accountable waste management system that truly protects our environment and public health.
Works cited
- Closing the Loop on the World’s Fastest-growing Waste Stream: Electronics | Baker Institute, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.bakerinstitute.org/research/closing-loop-worlds-fastest-growing-waste-stream-electronics
- Where does America’s e-waste end up? GPS tracker tells all | PBS News, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.pbs.org/newshour/science/america-e-waste-gps-tracker-tells-all-earthfix
- Hidden GPS Trackers Catch E-Waste Recyclers Exporting Toxic Electronics, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://incompliancemag.com/hidden-gps-trackers-catch-e-waste-recyclers/
- What links UK tyre exports to India’s toxic air and black market plants …, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.business-standard.com/health/uk-tyre-waste-india-pollution-pyrolysis-health-crisis-125032700522_1.html
- INDIA: The world’s dumping ground for waste tyres? – greaterkashmir, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.greaterkashmir.com/national/india-the-worlds-dumping-ground-for-waste-tyres/
- India: World’s dumping ground for waste tyres? – greaterkashmir, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.greaterkashmir.com/latest-news/india-worlds-dumping-ground-for-waste-tyres/
- 29th April 2025 – UK Parliament Considers Reforms to Strengthen Circular Economy for Tyres – TyreNews.co.uk, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.tyrenews.co.uk/news/parliament-considers-reforms-to-strengthen-circular-economy-for-tyres
- GPS Tracking Reveals U.S. E-Waste May Be Exported Illegally – Popular Mechanics, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/a20878/investigators-used-gps-to-track-us-toxic-electronic-waste-exports/
- Monitour: Tracking global routes of electronic waste | Request PDF – ResearchGate, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/321013996_Monitour_Tracking_global_routes_of_electronic_waste
- Tracking Devices Reveal Where Recycling Really Goes – YouTube, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hmGrI_BVlnc
- Monitour: Tracking global routes of electronic waste – MIT Senseable City Lab, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://senseable.mit.edu/papers/pdf/20171206_Lee-etal_Monitour_WasteManagement.pdf
- The deployment of electronic tracking devices to detect and prevent waste crime – SEPA, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.sepa.org.uk/media/407037/lsw-b7-waste-flow-tracking-devices-report.pdf
- Recycling of Tyres – Hansard – UK Parliament, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2025-04-29/debates/DF1C0690-5CAF-4B76-98FC-49F46D94ED16/RecyclingOfTyres
- Westminster Hall Debate in Full | Tyre and Rubber Recycling, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.tyreandrubberrecycling.com/articles/features/regulations-and-legislation/westminster-hall-debate-in-full/
- BBC Investigation: Millions of end-of-life tyres exported to illegal pyrolysis facilities, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://resource.co/article/bbc-investigation-millions-end-life-tyres-exported-illegal-pyrolysis-facilities
- Waste Management | Asian and Pacific Centre for Transfer of Technology – Apctt, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://apctt.org/vatis_update/waste-management-2
- This man put a GPS tracker in his recycling. Here’s where it ended up. – YouTube, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GK8mHhVngto
- This man put a GPS tracker in his recycling. Here’s where it … – CBS 8, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.cbs8.com/article/news/local/working-for-you/man-uses-gps-tracker-to-follow-plastic-recyclables/509-a16b8e3f-0b89-4911-be6d-8445d427d3bb
- Tracking where Starbucks single-use cups actually end up when …, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.cbsnews.com/losangeles/news/tracking-where-starbucks-single-use-cups-actually-end-up-when-recycled-kcal-investigations/
- Woman Disgusted When She Uses Tracker to See Where Her …, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://futurism.com/the-byte/gps-tracker-plastic-recycling
- Is your curbside recycling really being dumped in a landfill? | wthr.com, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.wthr.com/article/news/investigations/13-investigates/13-investigates-we-followed-your-curbside-recycling-with-gps-trackers-drones-and-undercover-cameras-heres-where-it-ended-up/531-e84b1de6-a855-412b-b5d6-194fd76cf803
- We used Apple AirTags to GPS track our plastic recycling | cbs8.com, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.cbs8.com/article/news/local/outreach/earth8/gps-tracking-plastic-recycling/509-0233a3d1-64b0-459c-ace9-49841ed75a7c
- Bloomberg investigation traces “recycled” plastic from Tesco in …, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://danwilcock.com/2022/04/14/bloomberg-investigation-traces-recycled-plastic-from-tesco-in-london/
- The Evolution of Commercial Rubbish Removal in London’s Business Districts, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://junkbunk.co.uk/blog/the-evolution-of-commercial-rubbish-removal-in-londons-business-districts/
- Digital Waste Tracking UK: What It Means and More – First Mile, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.thefirstmile.co.uk/the-big-picture/digital-waste-tracking
- Clinical Waste Disposal: Methods and Best Practices – The Environmental Blog, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.theenvironmentalblog.org/2025/04/clinical-waste-disposal/
- Artificial intelligence for waste management in smart cities: a review – PubMed Central, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10169138/
- From waste to steady income – Infrastructure Investor, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.infrastructureinvestor.com/from-waste-to-steady-income/
- Digital Waste Tracking Kicked Down the Road – Tyre and Rubber Recycling, accessed on May 13, 2025, https://www.tyreandrubberrecycling.com/articles/news/digital-waste-tracking-kicked-down-the-road/
.jpg)
